Serviceline Industrial Sensors
Serviceline Explosion Protection

Did You Find Out? Get the Answer to the Riddle of E-News Issue No. 1, February 2016


The broken window glass incident

Who kicked the ball and broke the window?
Who has shot the ball?

In a courtyard, four teenagers are playing soccer until one of them breaks a window. The homeowner takes the four teenagers to task, but only (exactly) one person tells the truth:

Nicolas: Elena has kicked the ball.
Marc: It was not me! 
Elena: Bastian did it.
Bastian: Elena is lying!

Can you figure out who has kicked the ball that broke the window?


Assuming that only one of the statements is true, the following applies:

  • If it was Nicolas, then Marc and Bastian are telling the truth.
  • If it was Elena, then Nicolas, Marc, and Bastian are telling the truth. 
  • If it was Bastian, then Marc and Elena are telling the truth.
  • If it was Marc, then only Bastian is telling the truth.

According to this reasoning, Marc kicked the ball that broke the window.


Subscribe to our newsletter and receive regularly news and interesting information around the world of automation.


Read the current issue of e-news: